Comments on: Kosovo a Muslim State in Europe http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/ fatihsyuhud.com an official blog / website of Indonesian blogger A. Fatih Syuhud Sun, 20 Jul 2008 21:58:38 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: yuki tobing http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2643 yuki tobing Tue, 01 Apr 2008 21:25:48 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2643 Hungary finally and surprisingly recognized Kosovo Independece, I am wondering what would happen to 200.000 Hungarian minorities in Vojvodina which sometimes had already been treated badly. Vuk Jeremic had criticized Hungary for this and stated that those who supported Kosovo independence could not expect to have a good relation with Serbia. Hungary finally and surprisingly recognized Kosovo Independece, I am wondering what would happen to 200.000 Hungarian minorities in Vojvodina which sometimes had already been treated badly. Vuk Jeremic had criticized Hungary for this and stated that those who supported Kosovo independence could not expect to have a good relation with Serbia.

]]> By: abu http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2251 abu Fri, 29 Feb 2008 17:38:45 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2251 Bosnia Herzegovina is the first moslem freedom nation in europe, isn't it? everything happens to Kosovo Right now is same with BosHeg few years ago, the different is BosHeg got the Freedom throught a sadistic war, Kosovo didn't, The Population Of BosHeg almost 100 % Moslem, I have no Idea about The Population of Kosovo. but, The Kosovian must be proud and happy to got their freedom. Bosnia Herzegovina is the first moslem freedom nation in europe, isn’t it? everything happens to Kosovo Right now is same with BosHeg few years ago, the different is BosHeg got the Freedom throught a sadistic war, Kosovo didn’t, The Population Of BosHeg almost 100 % Moslem, I have no Idea about The Population of Kosovo. but, The Kosovian must be proud and happy to got their freedom.

]]> By: olangbiaca http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2242 olangbiaca Thu, 28 Feb 2008 10:59:41 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2242 Aslkm... Kosovo and Turkey is the best Aslkm…

Kosovo and Turkey is the best

]]> By: Ujang http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2227 Ujang Wed, 27 Feb 2008 05:37:06 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2227 well as a moslem i'm happy to hear that kosovo has finally declared its independence, but as an Indonesian i'm a little bit worried about this, just think what if Aceh or Ambon do the same...well anyway I would congratulate to the people of Kosovo well as a moslem i’m happy to hear that kosovo has finally declared its independence, but as an Indonesian i’m a little bit worried about this, just think what if Aceh or Ambon do the same…well anyway I would congratulate to the people of Kosovo

]]> By: Toshihiko http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2202 Toshihiko Sun, 24 Feb 2008 03:23:08 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2202 Kosovo.... Is it the new Taiwan? why don't u discuss about this instead..? Kosovo…. Is it the new Taiwan? why don’t u discuss about this instead..?

]]> By: mulia http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2201 mulia Sun, 24 Feb 2008 02:27:30 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2201 <p>Colson, i agree with you about Turkey. I think mas Fatih, some how is being too sensitive about religion issue. As i get from BBC and Times, its more about the economic of the country. </p> <p>But on Kosovo, this time the independence is admnitted by USA, France and Great Britain. Thats all they need. Though Serbs are going to bring this case to the UN, it will never work unless they can lobby at least one of these countries. Therefore i think, this time its gona be different. </p> <p>I personally also dont see Kosovo as a significant moslem region. The Albanish i met, almost none of them practicing Islam. But i respect their believe, when they still say they are moslem. The thing is, as one can be Jew by descendance or Christian by nationality.., one can also be moslem for the same reason. In Indonesia, many are being moslem because they must identify their religion in the age of 17 *pertama bikin KTP.</p> <p>Mas Fatih, i think kapan kapan you should write about this new rapidly growing phenomenon, Islam KTP and the Indonesian neo-agnotism..hehe</p> # <blockquote>I think mas Fatih, some how is being too sensitive about religion issue</blockquote> <em>I dont think so Mulia. I've elaborated the issue in my oped piece (bahasa indonesia). see the link above.</em> Colson, i agree with you about Turkey. I think mas Fatih, some how is being too sensitive about religion issue. As i get from BBC and Times, its more about the economic of the country.

But on Kosovo, this time the independence is admnitted by USA, France and Great Britain. Thats all they need. Though Serbs are going to bring this case to the UN, it will never work unless they can lobby at least one of these countries. Therefore i think, this time its gona be different.

I personally also dont see Kosovo as a significant moslem region. The Albanish i met, almost none of them practicing Islam. But i respect their believe, when they still say they are moslem. The thing is, as one can be Jew by descendance or Christian by nationality.., one can also be moslem for the same reason. In Indonesia, many are being moslem because they must identify their religion in the age of 17 *pertama bikin KTP.

Mas Fatih, i think kapan kapan you should write about this new rapidly growing phenomenon, Islam KTP and the Indonesian neo-agnotism..hehe

#

I think mas Fatih, some how is being too sensitive about religion issue

I dont think so Mulia. I’ve elaborated the issue in my oped piece (bahasa indonesia). see the link above.

]]> By: colson http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2190 colson Fri, 22 Feb 2008 15:24:06 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2190 <p>A good post is one which incites controversy. So, let'start by saying that of course everybody is entitled to see it the way he/she wants it too see.</p> <p>However. Too much religion to my taste in this one.</p> <p>Over and over again Kosovo claimed independence from Serbia because they are Albanians. Not because religion is/was the big issue here. Fortunately not. Unfortunately in the civil war in Bosnia-Herzegowina it was.</p> <p>Living in the very South East it may seem Turkey belongs to Europe. And one may think that, if the EU hesitates about the country's membership of the EU, it has to be about the 80 million Muslims in that country.<br /> But, living in the North West of Europe myself, I differ of opinion. Well, I can see Istanbul is a Western, casus quo European, part of Turkey. But that's not the case with Anatolia. Let alone the more remote parts of Turkey. Their values are different, their habits are different, their culture is different, their economy is different, their history is different, their political system is different.</p> <p>It may amaze some, but objections against Turkey's membership at this moment, often are not those which people who tend to define the world in religious concepts, may think.</p> <em>#Colson, I love your comments, every bits of it. Really do. Thanks. </em> A good post is one which incites controversy. So, let’start by saying that of course everybody is entitled to see it the way he/she wants it too see.

However. Too much religion to my taste in this one.

Over and over again Kosovo claimed independence from Serbia because they are Albanians. Not because religion is/was the big issue here. Fortunately not. Unfortunately in the civil war in Bosnia-Herzegowina it was.

Living in the very South East it may seem Turkey belongs to Europe. And one may think that, if the EU hesitates about the country’s membership of the EU, it has to be about the 80 million Muslims in that country.
But, living in the North West of Europe myself, I differ of opinion. Well, I can see Istanbul is a Western, casus quo European, part of Turkey. But that’s not the case with Anatolia. Let alone the more remote parts of Turkey. Their values are different, their habits are different, their culture is different, their economy is different, their history is different, their political system is different.

It may amaze some, but objections against Turkey’s membership at this moment, often are not those which people who tend to define the world in religious concepts, may think.

#Colson, I love your comments, every bits of it. Really do. Thanks.

]]> By: kenken http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2180 kenken Fri, 22 Feb 2008 01:05:10 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2180 I agree with mulia, if turkish just an Islam KTP nation. I hope Kosovo people will can change europe opinion about moslem I agree with mulia, if turkish just an Islam KTP nation. I hope Kosovo people will can change europe opinion about moslem

]]> By: mulia http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2175 mulia Thu, 21 Feb 2008 20:20:35 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2175 <p>When BBC showed Turkish people demonstrated against the re-permission for moslem students to wear headscarf in university, my heart breaks..</p> <p>i guess, many of the Turkish are Islam KTP :(</p> <em>#tell u what, in Turkey you'll find it difficul to perform prayers in public places. student / teaching staffs in university will encourage you NOT to do shalah in campus. that's what my turkish friend once told me.</em> When BBC showed Turkish people demonstrated against the re-permission for moslem students to wear headscarf in university, my heart breaks..

i guess, many of the Turkish are Islam KTP :(

#tell u what, in Turkey you’ll find it difficul to perform prayers in public places. student / teaching staffs in university will encourage you NOT to do shalah in campus. that’s what my turkish friend once told me.

]]> By: Arif http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2171 Arif Thu, 21 Feb 2008 11:07:03 +0000 http://fatihsyuhud.com/2008/02/21/kosovo-a-muslim-state-in-europe/#comment-2171 <p>I guess Kosovo's majority people are a Catholic.</p> <p>About Turkey, Europe Union is reluctant to admit it as an european nation. Besides afraid of the difference of its religion, I think Europe also considered Turkey as a half Asian nation, not full europe.</p> #you may need this link for further reference on the country -> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo I guess Kosovo’s majority people are a Catholic.

About Turkey, Europe Union is reluctant to admit it as an european nation. Besides afraid of the difference of its religion, I think Europe also considered Turkey as a half Asian nation, not full europe.

#you may need this link for further reference on the country -> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo

]]>